The Dugout│Eight Sandy Koufax Rookie Cards Collectors Can't Resist

Explore our top Sandy Koufax rookie card picks that chronicle his stellar career. Learn why Koufax cards are creating a buzz in the hobby.

Updated Aug 23, 2023

Many companies on MoneyMade advertise with us. Opinions are our own, but compensation and in-depth research determine where and how companies may appear.

Sports Cards


Long Term Growth

1960s Dodgers legend Sandy Koufax dazzled the baseball world with his formidable pitching prowess. His curveballs and fastballs were game-changers, earning him the status of one of the all-time pitching greats.

1955 Topps Koufax #123 cards have fetched $8.4 million collectively across over 2,800 sales, attesting to the card's investment worthiness.

He won three Cy Young Awards, bagged four World Series titles, and even pitched a perfect game in 1965. But he quit early at age 30. His legend is unique, if a little mysterious.

This makes sports collectors really want his rookie cards. These cards aren't just pieces of cardboard—they're snapshots of a super-hot star in the world of baseball.

Who is Baseball Hall of Famer Sandy Koufax?

Sandy Koufax blazed a path through baseball history that still dazzles today. Famed for his ferocious fastballs and cunning curveballs, this pitching powerhouse claimed his first major league victory in 1955, silencing the Cincinnati Reds with 14 strikeouts.

In his career with the Dodgers—both in Brooklyn and Los Angeles—Koufax helped clinch four coveted World Series titles, underlining his indelible impact.

Between 1961 and 1966, Koufax was the trailblazer of baseball pitching, spinning a .655 winning percentage, a glittering 2.76 ERA, and a trifecta of pitching triple crowns that left jaws hanging in 1963, 1965, and 1966.

Just when everyone thought Koufax was winding down, this maven strutted into the limelight again after becoming the first to hurl four no-hitters, gifting the Dodgers their only perfect game in history.

Recognized as the youngest player ever inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, Koufax left an indelible mark, earning his pitcher stripes with more strikeouts than innings pitched, a rarity shared only with Randy Johnson, Pedro Martínez, and Nolan Ryan.

Why are Sandy Koufax baseball cards so valuable?

The Sandy Koufax rookie card is an iconic baseball memorabilia. Despite elbow arthritis curtailing his career, Koufax's stellar resume with three Cy Young Awards, four World Series titles, and one perfect game bolster the charm of his cards—especially his rookie cards.

Moreover, being part of memorable sets like the 1955 Topps makes them nostalgic keepsakes for collectors, further inflating their value. A standout is the 1955 Topps Sandy Koufax rookie card #123. Its handsome price and growing popularity underline its investment potential as a symbol of Koufax's baseball prowess.

Most valuable Sandy Koufax baseball cards

Sandy Koufax's cards are collector favorites—scarce, historically valuable, and with the star appeal of the acclaimed pitcher himself. Ignoring them could equate to striking out in the ninth inning of the World Series. Imagine the allure of the 1955 Topps Sandy Koufax #123 rookie card, the 1956 Topps Sandy Koufax #79, or the 1958 Topps #187.

1. 1962 Pittsburgh Exhibits Sandy Koufax (7 of Hearts)

  • Price Range: $1,715 to $5,660
  • Highest Sale Price: $5,657
  • PSA 9 Supply: 1
  • Type: Pittsburgh Exhibit

The 1962 Pittsburgh Exhibits Koufax card is worth between $1,715 and $5,660.

The 1962 Pittsburgh Exhibits Sandy Koufax (7 of Hearts) card is one of the rarest exhibit cards. It's exclusive to Pittsburgh's Kennywood Amusement Park and is worth $1,715 to $5,660. In the latest sale, a PSA 9 fetched a record $5,657 in a 2008 auction held by Mile High Card Company.

This PSA 9—the only one on record—encases a black-and-white print of Koufax with an artfully relocated copy signature, framed by a seven-of-hearts-style border. With only seven Seven of Hearts Koufax cards graded by PSA, gem mints are rare due to their subtly toned edges, which increase their appeal.

If you're planning to add this high-quality Koufax card to your collection, be prepared to shell out a minimum of $4,000. Rich in nostalgia, this card represents a prime investment opportunity.

2. 1967 Topps Venezuela Retirado #162

  • Price Range: $190 to $4,500
  • Highest Sale Price: $2,767
  • PSA 7 Supply: 2
  • Type: Venezuela Topps

The PSA near mint 1967 Topps Venezuela Retirado #162 is valued at $4,500.

The 1967 Topps Venezuela Retirado #162 card is super rare. You can spot it by the blue backdrop and the word "Retirado." Collectors would give anything to have it. It features a recently retired Koufax, making it a perfect fit for the Retirado series. One of these cards even sold for $2,767 in 2017, and that was just a PSA 4.

This card isn't shiny or made from strong card stock, so it can easily get worn out— making it even harder to find in good condition. Card grading is a super important factor in determining its price. Out of 19 cards sent to PSA, only one was graded 7.

3. 1957 Topps Sandy Koufax #302

  • Price Range: $33 to $37,770
  • Highest Sale Price: $32,770
  • PSA 9 Supply: 11
  • Type: Topps

A rare PSA mint 1957 Topps Koufax #302 card fetched $32,770 in October 2020 despite its printing flaws.

The 1957 Topps Sandy Koufax #302 card is a collector's dream. It stands out with its full-color photo and standard format. It's the hardest Koufax card to find in tip-top shape, which makes it more desirable.

Mint cards are more sought after because most examples often have issues with off-center images and printing errors. These elements create scarcity, which adds to the card's rarity and popularity.

This PSA mint 1957 Topps Sandy Koufax #302 card got snapped up for $17,980 at an April 2019 auction. Come October the next year, the card got a hefty bump—selling for $32,770. This shows just how valuable this little gem can be as an investment.

The hunt for PSA 10s is getting wild, especially since none have shown up yet. This makes the 1957 Topps Sandy Koufax #302 a truly rare find—a special blend of scarcity, rich history, and sheer style.

4. 1967 Topps Punch-Outs Sandy Koufax

  • Price Range: $229 to $700
  • Highest Sale Price: $736
  • PSA 7 Supply: 2
  • Type: Topps

A rare PSA 6-graded 1967 Topps Punch-Outs card featuring Koufax and Yastrzemski fetched $736 in 2007.
Image source:

Featuring the legendary Sandy Koufax and Carl Yastrzemski, the 1967 Topps Punch-Outs card is one of the rarest issues from the company. Sprinkling the fascination of Maryland's cello packs, the 2-1/2" by 4-2/3" gem with team captain Koufax gracing the front and an ingenious punching game at the back, draws investors with an insatiable appetite for rarity.

Selling for $736 back in a December 2007 auction, this PSA 6's value is likely to appreciate big-time. With only two cards graded PSA 7, finding higher grades could seriously boost your ROI.

5. 1962 Topps Sandy Koufax #5

  • Price Range: $25 to $12,000
  • Highest Sale Price: $24,651
  • PSA 9 Supply: 11
  • Type: Topps

A PSA Mint 1962 Topps Sandy Koufax #5 auctioned for $24,651 in 2008.
Image source:

Behold the 1962 Topps Sandy Koufax #5, rich in texture and history. It tantalizes collectors with its rarity: Out of 2,003 cards graded, only 11 boast a PSA 9, and there are no PSA 10s yet. This card occupies a strong market position—a PSA 9 card auctioned for a groundbreaking $24,651 in 2008, making it one of the most expensive Topps baseball cards depicting Koufax.

The card honors Koufax's stand-out 1961 season, where he shattered the strikeout record. But, the delicate wood-grain border is prone to chipping, an Achilles' heel that affects condition and value. This card isn't just a collectible, it's a high-stakes game of opportunity and risk.

6. 1958 Topps Sandy Koufax #187

  • Price Range: $50 to $6,500
  • Highest Sale Price: $449,389
  • PSA 10 Supply: 1
  • Type: Topps

The one-of-a-kind PSA gem mint 1958 Topps Sandy Koufax #187 fetched $449,389 at the Memory Lane Inc. auction house in May 2022.
Image source:

The PSA gem mint 1958 Topps Sandy Koufax #187 is a glossy jewel that boasts unrivaled charm for baseball aficionados. The allure of owning a piece of Koufax’s noble career makes it a tempting prospect for investors. This legendary Koufax card's story is one of a kind, and its rarity only boosts its worth.

A PSA 9 soared from $3,744 in 2016 to $4,975 in 2020. This trend, along with a PSA gem mint card selling for $449,389 in May 2022, shows that the #187 isn't just flashy—it could be a sweet path to big bucks.

7. 1956 Topps Sandy Koufax #79 (Gray Back)

  • Price Range: $100 to $24,000
  • Highest Sale Price: $49,000
  • PSA 10 Supply: 1 
  • Type: Topps

Koufax's 1956 Topps #79 (Gray Back) is rare with only one PSA 10 card in existence. 
Image source:

The 1956 Topps Sandy Koufax #79 (Gray Back) cranks up the nostalgia to the max. Dressed in enticing gray shades, it's a gem for those who love the uncommon. There's just a single gray back PSA 10 card out there, proving how rare it is.

A PSA gem mint fetching $49,000 at a 2009 auction proves the timeless appeal that Koufax brings to the hobby. Despite his shaky start with the Dodgers, his legacy triggers a collecting frenzy, making this card an investor's dream catch.

Still, centering problems can make it feel like a bit of a gamble. Expect a range of $100 for lesser grades up to $24,000 for a PSA 9 or higher—enticing even for rookies to the trading card game.

Feast your eyes on the vivid in-action shot and relish in its potential to boost your collection. But beware, its elusiveness might leave your gloves empty.

8. 1955 Topps Sandy Koufax Rookie Card #123

  • Price Range: $236 to $376,500
  • Highest Sale Price: $384,000
  • PSA 9 Supply: 25
  • Type: Topps

The 1955 Topps Sandy Koufax Rookie Card captures a golden era, with auction sales surpassing a cumulative $8.4 million.
Image source:

The 1955 Topps Sandy Koufax rookie card #123 is a snapshot of Koufax’s rise to fame and of the Brooklyn Dodgers' glory days.

The card’s sales history reveals some staggering figures. At Heritage Auctions' Fall Sports Collectibles Catalog Auction on November 20, 2021, a PSA 9 broke records when it raked in $384,000.

That sale ended the hot streak of PSA mint 1955 Topps Koufax #123 cards. Before that, one fetched $88,380 in October 2018 off the heels of a $90,000 sale at Heritage Auctions a few months earlier. Then, in May 2021, Goldin Auctions shattered the record after selling a PSA 9 for $369,000.

1955 Topps Koufax #123 cards have fetched $8.4 million collectively across over 2,800 sales, attesting to the card's investment worthiness. The history, uniqueness, and high demand make this gem so desirable, but snagging one of the 25 PSA 9's can be tricky.

Are Sandy Koufax baseball cards a good investment?

Sandy Koufax cards are inherently valuable historical keepsakes with a niche-yet-bustling market, and recent trends highlight an upward movement. Cards like the Koufax 1955 Topps rookie card #123 have shown impressive figures, fetching up to $384,000 for a single card, or $8.4 million in total for all 2,801 examples ever sold.

These rare cards illustrate Koufax's influential role in baseball, making them appealing to collectors. Notably, they've seen a buoyant market with a projected 40.96% raise over the next month and an annual increase of 30.21%, according to Cardbase.

While these figures point toward robust market performance, the decision to invest lies within personal preferences, budget, and risk appetite. With that in mind, step up to the plate if you’re looking to diversify with a high-ticket baseball card.

Find your next investment